What ‘unknown’ is correct about Bob Dylan

yesvery thing As Charles Péguy said, it begins in mysticism and ends in politics. Unless you’re Bob Dylan. If you’re Bob Dylan, you start politics and become mysterious. You start out as a hobo apprentice trying to sing the song of change. under protest You became the chosen spokesperson and prophet for the feeling of the Great Disruption aka the 60s; Then, after making a harsh gesture and separating, You withdraw. You make it concrete; You throw it all away And you drift into the contours of your being. Where will you be until They give you the Nobel Prize.–

Explore the January 2025 issue

Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read.

Anúncios

See more

by James Mangold complete unknownLike the best movies about rock stars—Sid and Nancy– Bohemian Rhapsody– control—It’s a fairy tale. It takes liberties: Dylanologists scream, it’s dramatized, it’s mythologised, it’s creative, it’s flexible, and it throws glittery showbiz confetti in the moments during which Dylan receives no publicity at all. Arrived in New York in 1961 and Maggie’s headlining appearances as Rebellious and Rebellious Wouldn’t Work Again on Maggie’s Farm Four Years Later at Newport Folk Festivalwhere His new electric sound drive Crazy old villagers and crowds (At least in Mangold’s films) all his bloodshed.

Timothée Chalamet plays Dylan, and he does a great job with his amnesia. He’s angry, twitching, mumbling, making up stories with Robert. Zimmerman in his youth Who is trying hard to break history and become Bob. Dylan has temporarily eroded his personality. Ed Norton, a high forehead that shines with compassion, plays Pete Seeger, the folk activist father whom Dylan will betray. Scoot McNairy plays Woody Guthrie, who is suffering from an illness. Huntington is strikingly wordless. at Greystone Park Psychiatric Hospital in New Jersey. Dylan traveled to Greystone with his guitar and fumbled for a beautiful, quirky bedside version of “Song to Woody”:

How did he do that? Why can someone from nowhere in their 20s create a sound that simultaneously sounds like both a crescendoing religious past and a grand future yet to come? How can we get along? It’s not his musicianship. as a guitarist He is a fool and a commoner. And now his formidable harmonica playing sounds like cartoon punctuation. The harmonica is less an instrument than a place to put its face after delivery. extra wavy lines But his youthful voice was bold and boundless. It is a tool for cutting through The world would have to wait for the Sex Pistols’ John Lydon to hear another voice crystallized in frozen rage.

And when his words or visions reached the level of nightmares—I saw a room full of men with bleeding hammers.—He sounds fearless but rousing, as if approaching and excusing himself with self-congratulation. Musician Robyn Hitchcock is listening to Dylan while quarantined in a boarding school in England. Feeling completely exposed As he explains in His latest memories 1967Dylan appears to have “accessed (or created?) a world outside of morality, faith, rules, or superstition:[he]has encountered a tragic and doomed realm where things They live simply – without a clear purpose – and their citizens wait haplessly for them. Fat.”

One of young Dylan’s basic lies as he stalks and talks around. Greenwich Village is that he learned to compose songs while Traveling with festivities– This is important. Because I began to suspect that there might be a great divide in American life. at The main division is the division between carnies and non-carnies. That is, among those who understand instinctively – in an animalistic way, sometimes – that life is a drama. People will believe what they want. And the most important thing is that it all happens in the imagination and … other people Carnies do not have much respect for reality. Because they know they can bend it and knock it over. Non-carnies are condemned to the facts – for what Stanley Elkin calls “prey hunters.”

Is Young Bob a crybaby? He wanted to be, and compared to the brave and noble Seeger, He was definitely like that. His identity is acting. His writing is agile. He impresses and stuns his audience and when. complete unknownHe reworks the carnival story of Joan Baez (Monica Barbaro) with the addition of a cowboy guitarist named Wigglefoot. She looks at him and says—deadpanned with excitement—“You really are full of nonsense.” Which is exactly what you said to carny.

And it was a very dramatic performance. in how they praised him adorn him and established him as the Voice of a Generation (not all contemporary versions of his songs are covers of his songs, except for Hendrix’s smoking hot “All along the Watchtower”). Now that sounds like a misunderstanding or a mistranslation, right?) The villagers’ seriousness and humorlessness were unbelievable. He came to save us all. The path is unbroken: from Woody Guthrie to Bob Dylan, the torch has passed.

Except, if you’re Bob Dylan, there’s no torch, and there’s no one to pass it on. Therefore he must be perverted, disruptive, ungrateful, and panicked. And made a sound that would frighten poor old Seeger: punk rock. before the letter– complete unknown Create a villain, especially from Alan Lomax, which is interesting: in the film The famous activist and archivist became a gangster folk boss, cursing Dylan for his impurity and arguing with his manager Albert Grossman during a Newport set.

In the Newport scene the crowd cheered in embarrassment. The film switches between different events. It’s really surprising. History records that Lomax actually argued with Grossman. But no one at Newport shouted “Judas!” at Bob Dylan: That won’t happen until next year, when? He plays the Free Trade Hall in Manchester, England.– and Ian Bell for his story Once Upon a Time: The Life of Bob Dylanpoints out that the mostly hip Newport festival audience probably knew what to expect from Dylan that day: “’Maggie’s Farm’ is supposedly the root cause of Newport’s problems. all of that It’s not a secret at all. And it came as no surprise to anyone who cared even a little about Dylan by the time the festival started.” (Dylan keyboardist Al Kooper said “85 to 90 percent” of the crowd enjoyed Dylan’s performance.)

But so what? complete unknown It’s a movie and a movie or this type of movie. which in a sense is a metaphor for artistic brutality. A climax was needed, and Bob Dylan, more than most rock stars, was a legend. In every sense of the word He created himself, he disappeared, and in doing so He became a lens. Aura of insight from another world flowed towards him. And he trains them for us like a person frying ants with a magnifying glass.

He had glowing visions and torture chambers in his mind. He could make God and Abraham talk to each other like two hustlers on a street corner. He lets everyone down, abandons everyone, and then teaches them to feel joy from that abandonment. Something in me wanted to talk about the heavy rain that was falling right now. And I wonder who will step up and sing about this rain. Who will be the singers of our last days? Our undeceived guiding voice, etc. But to ask such questions—to think in those terms—is to make a big mistake, right? And this is the end of Bob Dylan’s lesson.

This article appeared in January 2025 print edition with the title “Bob Dylan’s Carnival Act” when you purchase the book using the links on this page. We will earn commission. Thank you for your support. atlantic ocean